Supporting actors usually play the most interesting roles. Under appreciated actors tend to inhabit their roles so well, that the actors receive less credit than they deserve. Thus under appreciated supporting actors are those who have routinely excelled in various roles without the attention that they might merit. This list is not a compilation of the best supporting performances, so do not complain that Heath Ledger was excluded since he did star in the critically acclaimed A Knight’s Tale. That said, please let me know what you think of this list, especially if you agree with my choices.
Robert Shaw in From Russia With Love, 1963
Robert Shaw plays dangerous like no other actor. As Grant, an agent of SPECTRE, he gave James Bond all that he could handle. He made From Russia With Love a classic far more than the shoe-knifed Rosa Klebb. His Quint from Jaws is the second most memorable part of that film—second to the giant shark. His treacherous “Blue” in the original Taking of Pelham One Two Three showcased a new breed of intelligent criminal who would become popular in modern cinema. Yet his only Oscar nomination came for his portrayal of King Henry VIII in A Man For All Seasons. An under appreciated Oscar nomination? I bet most people reading this did not know that A Man For All Seasons won the best picture Oscar, and even if they did that it was about Sir Thomas More.
Ellen Page & J.K. Simmons, Juno 2007. ©Fox Searchlight.
Co-star of the big screen and the small, J.K. Simmons can play daft all the way to bright. On that spectrum I list his roles as Spider-Man/2 (J. Jonah Jameson, publisher of The Daily Bugle), the video game Portal 2, The Ladykillers (explosives “expert” Garth Pancake), Burn After Reading (CIA superior), Hidalgo (Buffalo Bill Cody), Up in the Air (Bob, one of the fired employees), Juno (Mac MacGuff), For Love of the Game (Frank Perry, Tigers manager), and “Law & Order” (Emil Skoda, psychologist). He is so good I even tried to watch an episode of “The Closer” for him and the guy who played Capt. Harris in the Police Academy movies. Unfortunately even he could not save it, similar to his valiant effort in Burn After Reading.
Jon Polito as Johnny Caspar, Millers Crossing, 1990
Jon Polito’s face alone could crack my top ten for supporting actors, but once you add in his Italian-American accent, hooooo-eeee, he made this list easily. Miller’s Crossing probably does not even crack into my top three for his favorite roles. For me those are the “Brother Seamus” in The Big Lebowski, Det. Steve Crosetti “Homicide”, and then as the role that must have gotten him Miller’s Crossing Phil Bartoli, the Chicago mafia kingpin in “Crime Story.”
Martin Balsam as Juror #1, 1957.
Martin Balsam plays key roles in some classic films: 12 Angry Men, Psycho, Murder on the Orient Express, and The Taking of Pelham One Two Three. Not a controversial choice, but this is someone who should be brought to the attention of all serious film fans who are interested in looking back into film history.
Gina McKee as Marion Nell, Croupier, 1998
I fell in love with Gina McKee in Croupier. Clive Owen starred in it with dyed blonde hair and he went on to become a star, but Croupier works because Owen’s girlfriend seemed so caring, so imperfect and so real. Most people know McKee from playing the wheelchair bound Bella in Notting Hill, but she also deserves fans for her work in ensemble pieces such as in the road to war black comedy In The Loop, the British “The Forsyte Saga” where she marries the wrong man, and the medieval mystery The Reckoning. I hope she grows into the Helen Mirren roles in a few years.
I do not remember the first time I watched “Newsradio,” but I do know that I thought that Stephen Root was in the top 6 funniest people on that show. That is more a testament to the shocking comedic collection that NBC had aggregated than a criticism of Mr. Jimmy James. It really was not until his subtle turn as the man who sets Anton Chigurh on the warpath in No Country For Old Men that I realized how impressive his career has been. He has been all over the place: playing Milton in Office Space—all he wants is his red stapler back—to voice acting as Bill on “King of the Hill” to a closeted homosexual sheriff in Red State. No matter what the role, he seems to pull it off.
Danny Huston as Arthur Burns in The Proposition
Danny Huston is almost a good enough actor to make a crappy movie into something good, like X-Men Origins: Wolverine. Oh well. He uses his American accent well in Silver City. Yet, He is at his best when he gets to use his wonderful English accent in like The Proposition, The Constant Gardener, and Children of Men. He is a delightfully frightening actor.
Mark Strong and Robert Downey, Jr. in Sherlock Holmes, 2009
Another delightfully frightening villainous actor is Mark Strong. He played Lord Blackwood in Sherlock Holmes, Sorter in Revolver, Frank D’Amico in Kick-Ass, Godfrey in Robin Hood, Clive Cornell in The Guard, and Sinestro in Green Lantern. But he has more range than that, as can be seen in the complex British Agent Jim Prideaux in Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy. If he were only a bit more traditionally attractive, he could have been a huge star, but thanks to some crappy Guy Ritchie movies, he has finally gotten his chance to shine in these supporting roles.
Jackie Earle Haley as Rorschach in Watchmen, both in costume and out.
Kelly Leak was a major character in The Bad News Bears in 1976. Jackie Earle Haley’s career was all downhill thence until his retirement in 1993. Thirteen years later Haley returned in a movie I have not seen called Little Children and he got nominated for best supporting actor. Three types of people get nominated for best supporting actor: (1) stars who were not good enough to win in their starring roles, (2) young actors on the rise to stardom, and (3) deserving supporting actors. He lost of Alan Arkin a (1) who is now a (3). Anyways, Haley has a fire that makes his small frame almost seethe when angry, which made him perfect for Rorschach and the VP of the Confederacy in Lincoln.
Kevin Pollak in The Usual Suspects, 1995.
Rounding out my first ten under appreciated supporting actors is Mr. Hockney himself, Kevin Pollak. He is another short actor, but he has played a wide swath of character, ranging from the comedic to the serious. Hockney was the best of both worlds and made him seem like a bigger star to me than audiences ever did. Some of his credits include A Few Good Men, Red State, The Whole Nine Yards, Casino, Willow, L.A. Story… I could keep going with this or with more actors, but I should stop at ten, as Matthew Perry fortunately did with The Whole Ten Yards.