*½
Cinderella, this can’t be what your daddy had in mind for you, baby.
The year is 1997. Pop-singer Brandy is cast in a made-for-TV version of Cinderella. No expense is spared on the out of the box casting. I personally thought that the mishmash of ethnicities for the characters was fine. The Prince, played by a Filipino actor named Paolo Montalban, comes from an interracial royal couple played by Whoopi Goldberg and Victor Garber (the dad on “Alias”). I don’t think that the film is trying assert that a black American and a white American having a child would be Filipino, but more that the race and ethnicity of characters are not relevant in this fairy tale. That is a nice message and led to some cool casting. The only problem is that the crux of Cinderella is that the Prince does not know the name of the girl he’s fallen in love with, nor can he apparently recognize her. The Prince isn’t presented as a moron, but it’s hard not to think of him as such when he cannot even remember something like her skin color. Of all of the fairy tales that Disney adapted, this might be the least suited to casting like this.
A counterpoint that one of my cousin’s raised in response to this was that it’s a fairy tale and a magic shoe might magically fit only one person. I wish the writers could have used magic to come up with a decent punchline for some of these wonderful actors to deliver. Of note, Jason Alexander and Bernadette Peters made me laugh through sheer comic force of will. On the other hand, I thought that Whitney Houston’s Fairy Godmother was disappointing. I also didn’t feel like Cinderella really spent that much time right by the fire – and if the movie cannot convince me that Cinderella’s cruel nickname is legitimate, then the whole story falls apart.
If there is a positive from this adaptation of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s Cinderella, it’s that clearly both Rodgers and Hammerstein were holding back. They kept the enduring melodies and great lyrics for The Sound of Music. I would rather have one great musical than two pretty good ones.