***
Could you write five thousand words on the influence of Norse elements in Gawain?
This movie really reminded me of The Imitation Game. I couldn’t remember that movie title, so I wrote “The Enigma Machine”, and that is not as crazy as you might think. If you type “Enigma” into IMDb’s search the second option that drops down is The Imitation Game. A movie that I found to be generally overrated. It’s good, but not great. In Tolkien Nicholas Hoult does his Benedict Cumberbatch impression of an awkward genius and the result is fine. Substitute World War I for World War II and then the movies are even closer. The reasons for the existence of these two films are what I find truly interesting.
The Imitation Game is an apology to the memory of an important figure in human history, Alan Turing. We watch that film with a sense of guilt. The film serves as a warning, that when we mistreat society’s outcasts, we might be mistreating the ones we need to save us. It is a selfish message, but by making it feel personal, the audiences reacted strongly to it. Tolkien taps into those same feelings, through World War I, and the importance of relationships, but the major difference is what brought us into this movie – love. I love The Lord of the Rings and The Hobbit. According to the special features on the Lord of the Rings films, The Lord of the Rings is the second most read book of all-time, after the Bible. The guilt the audience feels in this film stems from how much happier our lives are than J.R.R. Tolkien’s. We are shown where Sauron comes from. Where Tolkien’s love of lore comes from. Both of those are places of great pain. The film says, had Tolkien not suffered, he would not have created the things that we love. Although, in the end he shares and expands his creations out of love.
Director Dome Karukoski made the film for $20M and it looks great for such a low budget, particularly considering that it includes war scenes. That it did not earn that money back is unfortunate, because the movie was very competently composed and presented. Hopefully he gets another shot with another English language film. The other comments I have are that Lily Collins was very good as Edith Bratt, Tolkien’s future wife. That Derek Jacobi was perfectly cast as the expert, hard-ass professor. And that Colm Meaney—Star Trek’s Chief O’Brien—was, as always, a treat.